“Shattered Lands” Sam Dalrymple (2025) Review | Making of new Asia

★★★★★  5 Partitions, not just one. From Yemen to Myanmar, The British India was one entity where cosmopolitan people had lived in a sort of harmony. An important history that was until now “forgotten”, and an important book.

🔽 log 🔽
Shattered Lands
Five Partitions and the Making of Modern Asia
Sam Dalrymple, 2025
UK
528 pages
Read 2025.09


🔽 Book review and notes 🔽
A great book on the topic that is shamefully unknown to a lot of us, even though it's not so long time ago and even though it totally shaped Asia today.
All the problems in Asia that we see on the news today are not simply because the local people are "naturally" violent, of course not, there is always a cause. 

And the cause is, this. The British Empire had ruled and gained much from the British India and local Princely States (so very wide, from modern day Yemen to Burma, to Qatar. Qatar! And British Empire had 25% of the world population back then) until one day they couldn't financially support it so they dropped the ball, without thinking of the very probable consequences, namely, the shattered lands and shattered people.

The book carefully follows 5 Partitions, rather than only the more widely known THE Partition between today's India and Pakistan. 
Myanmar, Arabian peninsula, India-Pakistan, Princely States, and Bangladesh.
People like me who knew so little would be surprised at how everything fell apart quickly, and be utterly shocked how millions of people crossed newly drawn borders each time. And every one experienced some horror; the violence, looting, rape, and many killing.
The consequences of the relocation, the migration, and of course of refugees like Rohingya people still remains as huge problems. 

Stereotypically, British officers’ works were full of lies and betrayals, their selfishness with their strong interesting in keeping their hands clean.
As a predicable result, people who lived in cosmopolitan societies, were suddenly put in various corners of Shattered Lands, and they turned against their neighbours because they now became their enemies.

What got me thinking most throughout my reading was how pre Partitions era things were more secular, and as the lands got divided it firmly became a matter of religions and ethnicity, it was all about nationalism, of the new nations that were born out of the shattered lands – again and again in the each phase of the Partitions.
Not that the colonisation era was good, but you cannot stop wondering, if we now want to end the fighting in Asia would we have to eliminate the notions of religion and ethnicity?
Letting go of the sense of community or tradition? The peace of mind it provides?
Is it really a dangerous thing to have a tradition?

I heard somewhere that people who experienced the Partitions, probably just like our grandfathers in Japan who were sent to the war, have preferred to keep quiet.
They chose to take the horror, errors and shame to their graves, and their children also kind of hesitated to insist.
However, now that it’s their grandchildren’s generation, things are now becoming uncovered and dusted off because they are finally opening their mouths to tell us.
And this might be one of the reasons why this book is written now at this moment in time, by this brilliant author who is in his 20s, and this is one of the reason this book will remain in the history to come.

The book has great details with wonderful storytelling skills, and most notably it has the marvelous sense of humanity, just like his father, Sam Dalrymple is such a humane human full of compassion and passion, with giggles – but he is already on his own feet, and how exciting is it that two Dalrymples are on the chart? Very.

🔽 Where to buy 🔽

●●● Amazon.com (US) ●●●

Shattered Lands: Five Partitions and the Making of Modern Asia

●●● Amazon.co.uk (UK) ●●●
Shattered Lands: INTERNATIONALLY BESTSELLING AND PRIZE SHORTLISTED NEW HISTORY OF FIVE PARTITIONS AND THE RESHAPING OF MODERN ASIA

●●● Amazon.it (Italy) ●●●
Shattered Lands: INTERNATIONALLY BESTSELLING AND PRIZE SHORTLISTED NEW HISTORY OF FIVE PARTITIONS AND THE RESHAPING OF MODERN ASIA